Base oils are the foundation for the production of a wide range of lubricants, process fluids, and other petrochemical products. With ever-increasing demands for performance, reliability, and sustainability, choosing the right type of base oil has become crucial. Despite the emergence of more advanced synthetic groups, I and II group base oils still hold a significant market share and play a pivotal role in many petrochemical processes due to their cost-effectiveness and adaptability through additives.
The API (American Petroleum Institute) classification divides base oils into five groups. We will focus on the first two groups, as they are the most common and economically significant for many applications.
Group I base oils are produced by solvent extraction of residual raw materials obtained during oil refining. During the production process, undesirable components such as sulfur compounds, aromatic hydrocarbons, and resins are removed.
The resulting base oils have a moderate viscosity index ranging from 80 to 100. They are generally characterized by a higher content of sulfur (> 0.03%) and aromatic hydrocarbons, as well as lower oxidative and thermal stability compared to Group II, and have a very valuable and important property: a relatively low production cost.
Group II base oils can be described as improved base oils, if we may be so bold. They are produced by the hydrocracking process, which involves the intense application of hydrogen under high pressure and temperature in the presence of catalysts. This process not only removes heteroatoms and aromatics, but also leads to the isomerization of hydrocarbons, making them more saturated.
Group II base oils are characterized by a higher viscosity index (VI) in the range of 100-120. They have a significantly lower sulfur content (< 0.03%) and aromatic hydrocarbon content, as well as significantly improved oxidative and thermal stability.
The main advantage of these base oils is their improved performance, wider temperature range, and increased durability.
The main difference between Group II and Group I base oils is their deeper purification and refining process, which results in their better thermo-oxidative properties.
The main physical and chemical properties that are most important for petrochemicals are:
- Viscosity index of base oils, which determines how much the viscosity of the oil changes with temperature. For petrochemical processes, viscosity stability is important to ensure reliable operation of equipment in the specified temperature ranges. Group II base oils are usually superior to group I oils;
- Oxidation and thermal stability. This property of base oils is critical in high-temperature and long-term load conditions typical of petrochemical industries. Base oils with high stability degrade less, form less deposits, and last longer. Group II has a clear advantage;
- Impurities content (sulfur, aromatic hydrocarbons). The low content of these substances in Group II base oils reduces the risks of corrosion, deposits, and improves overall compatibility with equipment materials, and most importantly, reduces the environmental impact;
- Low-temperature properties. The pour point and dynamic viscosity at low temperatures determine the ability of oils to operate in cold regions or in low-temperature processes. Group II generally demonstrates better performance.
The choice between Group I and Group II base oils is often dictated by a balance between performance requirements and cost.
For less demanding applications, such as general-purpose hydraulic systems, circulating oils, and mid-range transmission oils, where stability and cleanliness are not as critical, Group I base oils may be the most cost-effective solution.
However, in more critical systems, particularly those with high temperatures, pressures, and long replacement intervals, Group II base oils may be preferred. For example, in gas-pumping compressors and high-performance hydraulic systems.
Base oils also serve as the basis for the production of plasticizers and other chemical components, as well as lubricants, coolants, and heat transfer fluids. In these cases, the properties of the base oil directly affect the quality of the final product.
It is impossible to talk about Group I and II base oils without mentioning the role of additives, which are an integral part of most final products and allow you to compensate for the lack of properties of Group I base oils and enhance the benefits of Group II base oils. Antioxidant, anti-wear, detergent, dispersant, and depressant additives significantly improve the characteristics of these groups of oils and allow you to unlock the full potential of the base oils, adapting them to the most challenging tasks.
Perhaps the most important criterion when choosing a base oil is the ratio of economic and operational aspects, or, in simpler terms, the price/quality ratio.
The cost of Group I base oils is significantly lower, which is a result of their cheaper production, and this factor makes them attractive for mass-produced and non-critical applications. Group II oils are more expensive, but their use can reduce overall operating costs by extending the life of equipment, reducing downtime, and reducing the need for refilling. It is also worth considering the fact that environmental requirements are gradually becoming stricter, such as sulfur content and emission standards, which increases the demand for Group II base oils.
In conclusion of our brief description of one of the types of products produced by the Kemin Refinery, it can be noted that Group I and II base oils remain the cornerstone of the petrochemical industry. Group I base oils continue to be in demand due to their economic accessibility for standard tasks, while Group II base oils offer higher performance and reliability, serving as a bridge to synthetic oils and a suitable solution for tasks that require robust solutions for more demanding operating conditions. Choosing the right base oil in combination with the right additive package is key to ensuring the longevity of your equipment, reducing maintenance costs, and improving the overall efficiency of your production processes.